{ "schema_version": "1.0", "brief": { "id": "WHW-COMMISSION-2026-08-25-FAMILY-PRODUCTS", "date": "2026-08-25", "status": "ready-to-commission", "owner": "Wong Hong Wei", "purpose": "Obtain qualified, independent review of the exact child-and-family product artifacts before educational, developmental, safeguarding, accessibility, paid-distribution or institutional claims are made.", "independence_boundary": "AI-assisted internal review prepared and prioritised this work, but it is not a substitute for the named human reviewers. Reviewers must disclose conflicts and review the supplied content hashes.", "shared_deliverables": [ "Item- or activity-level decision: approve for bounded practice, revise, or withhold.", "Reason for every revise or withhold decision, with an authoritative source or professional-practice basis where applicable.", "Exact replacement wording for high-priority defects when feasible.", "Reviewer name, role, relevant qualification or lived or professional expertise, organisation if any, review date, conflict disclosure and reviewed artifact hash.", "A short residual-risk note explaining what the review does not establish." ], "acceptance_rules": [ "Approval applies only to the exact reviewed content hash; a material content change invalidates it.", "A reviewer may cover more than one lens only where their qualifications genuinely cover each lens.", "Child or caregiver testing requires informed adult consent, age-appropriate assent, data minimisation and a written safeguarding and stopping protocol.", "No engagement may be described as certification, efficacy evidence or institutional endorsement unless the commissioned method and reviewer explicitly support that claim." ] }, "manual_reviewer_verification": { "purpose": "A named accountable human records how a reviewer's identity and relevant credentials were checked without publishing sensitive identity material.", "blank_receipt": "/data/reviews/2026-08-25-manual-reviewer-verification-receipt-template.json", "validation_command": "node scripts/validate-manual-reviewer-verification-receipt.mjs ", "storage_boundary": "Keep raw evidence, nonces, contact details and identity documents outside the public repository. Publish no completed receipt without a separate privacy review.", "automation_boundary": "A valid receipt proves only record, hash and date consistency. It cannot prove identity, credentials, evidence authenticity, independence or professional judgement and must never trigger automatic release." }, "workstreams": [ { "priority": 1, "product_id": "everyday-hero-quest", "commission": "Scenario-level safeguarding, digital-safety and primary-education adjudication", "review_unit": "Every scenario prompt, response option, explanation and caregiver framing, identified by stable ID and content hash.", "minimum_reviewers": [ "Singapore primary educator", "child-safeguarding professional", "digital-safety specialist", "accessibility or neurodiversity-informed reviewer", "caregiver usability reviewer" ], "first_pass_scope": "All 31 paused and two tier-3 not-queued scenarios first, followed by a risk-based pass over 51 active scenarios.", "decision_gate": "No paused or tier-3 item returns to a child-facing queue until every required lens for that item records a hash-bound outcome.", "artifact": "/data/everyday-hero/scenario-register.json", "review_return_template": "/data/everyday-hero/review-return-template.json", "validation_command": "node scripts/validate-everyday-hero-review-return.mjs " }, { "priority": 2, "product_id": "foxys-learning-patch", "commission": "Activity-level early-years, speech-language, multilingual and accessibility review", "review_unit": "Every guided activity, prompt, feedback string, audio or visual cue, caregiver note and off-screen mission.", "minimum_reviewers": [ "early-childhood educator with experience around ages 18 months to 3 years", "speech-language professional", "native Singapore Mandarin or Simplified-Chinese reviewer", "native Singapore Malay reviewer", "accessibility tester covering keyboard, screen reader, reduced motion, sound-off and touch use" ], "first_pass_scope": "Three Minutes Together and every Mandarin or Malay vocabulary and feedback path, then the full activity inventory.", "decision_gate": "Do not make developmental, language-learning or accessibility-conformance claims until the relevant specialist has reviewed the exact artifact.", "artifact": "/data/reviews/2026-08-25-foxy-specialist-review-packet-e8aad3ef5cd8.json", "roadmap_decision": "Tamil is not currently a Foxy product language. Commission Tamil localization separately only if it becomes an explicit product decision.", "source_artifact": "/foxys-learning-patch/", "review_packet": "/data/reviews/2026-08-25-foxy-specialist-review-packet-e8aad3ef5cd8.json", "verification_command": "node scripts/build-foxy-specialist-review-packet.mjs --check", "review_return_template": "/data/reviews/2026-08-25-foxy-specialist-review-return-template-e8aad3ef5cd8.json", "validation_command": "node scripts/validate-foxy-specialist-review-return.mjs " }, { "priority": 3, "product_id": "primary-power-quest-sg", "commission": "Question-bank and generator validation for P1-P3 English, Mathematics, Chinese and Science", "review_unit": "A reproducible stratified sample plus all generator rules, answer keys, explanations and difficulty labels.", "minimum_reviewers": [ "Singapore P1-P3 English educator", "Singapore P1-P3 Mathematics educator", "Singapore P1-P3 Chinese educator", "Singapore P1-P3 Science educator", "accessibility and caregiver-usability reviewer" ], "first_pass_scope": "At least 30 reproducibly seeded items per level-subject cell, every template family, all edge cases and every claimed difficulty transition.", "decision_gate": "Do not claim curriculum alignment, assessment validity, readiness, mastery or calibrated difficulty from generator tests alone.", "artifact": "/data/reviews/2026-08-25-primary-power-educator-review-packet-747c8ed9a447.json", "source_artifact": "/primary-power-quest-sg/", "review_packet": "/data/reviews/2026-08-25-primary-power-educator-review-packet-747c8ed9a447.json", "verification_command": "node scripts/build-primary-power-review-packet.mjs --check", "review_return_template": "/data/reviews/2026-08-25-primary-power-educator-review-return-template-747c8ed9a447.json", "validation_command": "node scripts/validate-primary-power-review-return.mjs " } ], "optional_follow_on_study": { "name": "Observed caregiver-child usability pilot", "start_only_after": "The three expert content-review workstreams have closed critical defects.", "purpose": "Observe comprehension, stopping behaviour, caregiver burden and accessibility barriers; not measure learning efficacy.", "minimum_method": "Small moderated sessions with a written protocol, informed adult consent, child assent where appropriate, no sensitive profiling, predefined stopping rules and a de-identified issue log." } }