Hu before set claims
An eligible Hu is resolved before a competing Pong, Kong or Chi, even when the set claimant sits nearer to the discarder.
Rules Atlas · Claim priority
Multiple winners in Singapore Mahjong
When one discard lets two players Hu, the table must choose between one nearest winner and multiple winners before play. That decision changes both the result and payments.
Written by Wong Hong Wei · Reviewed · Scope: Wong practice table v1
Direct answer
The Wong playable table uses one nearest winner: Hu outranks Pong, Kong and Chi, then the nearest eligible Hu caller in normal turn order wins. It does not settle two winners from one discard.
The exact practice-table rule
Nearest eligible Hu
Check the three other seats in ordinary turn order after the discarder. The first eligible Hu caller takes the discard and ends the hand.
One settlement
Only that winner receives the winning-hand payment. Dealer and round progression follow that single result.
Worked scenarios
South and West can both Hu
East discards Five Circles. South is next in turn order and West follows. Both hands are otherwise legal.
Result here: South wins. West's possible Hu is not separately settled.
A farther Hu beats a nearer Pong
South can Pong East's discard, but West can Hu it.
Result here: West wins. Hu priority is tested before lower set claims.
Documented alternative
Some rulesets permit every eligible player to win on the same discard. That profile must also define whether the discarder pays each winner independently, how Bao applies, who becomes dealer and how the round advances. The companion can record a multiple-winner preference; the current playable game remains nearest-winner only.
Do not change only the label. A multiple-winner table also needs an explicit payment and continuation rule.
Canonical rule record
This evidence block is generated from the public v1 registry. The legacy API key multiple-winners remains supported; SGMJ-MULTIPLE-WINNERS-001 is the stable cross-page identifier.
| Rule dimension | Machine key | Site default |
|---|---|---|
| Policy | policy | Nearest one |
| Priority | priority | Nearest eligible player in turn order |
| Multiple Settlement | multipleSettlement | No |
Check a table situation. The picker offers conditional examples, not a ruling on an unseen hand. Live replay currently covers the five Ping Hu worked hands only; Bao, passed claims and multiple-call positions remain unavailable.
Published deterministic fixtures
nearest-hu-priority— Winner: South; Winner Count: 1nearest-hu-before-pong— Claim: Humultiple-profile-allows-callers— score each winner under the table payment rule
Registry 2026.08.26: canonical rules · fixtures. These records verify this site's chosen behaviour; they do not claim that all Singapore tables use it. Independent Mahjong-expert and fluent Chinese-language review remain pending.
Source comparison and provenance
- App behaviour: the current game resolves eligible Hu callers in turn order before testing Pong, Kong or Chi; repository tests cover two Hu callers and Hu-versus-Pong priority.
- Site specification: the pre-game checklist states the nearest-winner practice-table choice.
- External comparison: SingaporeMahjong.com and the SPGG competition rules describe their own scopes, not universal authority.
Registry: rule data · public deterministic examples · review method.
Multiple-winner FAQ
Can two players win on the same discard in this game?
No. The Wong practice table awards the discard to the nearest eligible Hu claimant in turn order, so one player wins the hand.
Does Hu have priority over Pong or Chi?
Yes. An eligible Hu is resolved before Pong, Kong or Chi; among eligible Hu callers, the nearest player in turn order has priority under the playable table default.
Can the table companion record a multiple-winner house rule?
Yes. The companion profile can record that choice, but the group must also agree how each winner is paid and how the next dealer is chosen. The playable game itself remains nearest-winner only.